Printful vs Printify

Disclaimer: Some of the content on this site contains affiliate links, meaning that if you click on them, we might earn a commission at no cost to you. This doesn’t affect our honest and thorough reviews in any way but helps us maintain the research conducted by our team.

Are you having trouble choosing between Printful and Printify? Well, fret not; you have come to the right place.

As both PoD platforms are high-quality and great competitors, it is no mystery why you or anyone would have difficulty choosing between them.

Both print-on-demand services do a good job, but it’s important to note that they are very different. Let’s dive right into this Printful vs Printify review.

The Verdict: For those serious about creating a Print on Demand drop shipping online store, Printful, with its superior quality and better scalability options, is the ultimate all-around platform.

Here’s a detailed comparison table of Printful vs Printify, including features and ratings for each:

Feature Comparison Table:

Summary:

• Printful is ideal for high-quality products, excellent branding options, and reliable global shipping. It’s slightly more expensive but offers superior control over product quality and customer experience.
• Printify is better for those who prioritize variety and cost-effectiveness, making it suitable for businesses aiming for higher profit margins with competitive pricing. However, more vigilance is required regarding supplier quality and shipping times.

Both platforms are strong contenders in the print on demand space, each catering to slightly different business needs.

Popularity Comparison: Printful vs Printify (2021 – 2023)

Printful vs Printify: A Comprehensive Review

When you’re starting a print-on-demand (POD) business, two of the most popular platforms you’ll come across are Printful and Printify. Both offer a variety of services, but deciding which one is better suited for your needs requires a deep dive into factors like pricing, print quality, profit margins, and more. Let’s compare Printful and Printify across several key aspects.

1. Pricing and Plans

Printful operates on a free-to-use model with no upfront costs. you only pay for the goods and services you order.

Printify, on the other hand, also offers a free version, but its premium plan is priced more affordably at $29 per month.

Printify Premium allows you to unlock up to 20% discounts on all products, which can significantly boost your profit margins, especially when you’re processing high volumes of orders.

Additionally, Printify offers an Enterprise plan for large-scale businesses, where custom pricing and features are available.

Winner: Printify – It’s more cost-effective for larger-scale businesses due to its cheaper premium plan and product discounts.

2. Profit Margins

Printful charges higher prices for their products, but this can be justified by their generally better print quality (as we’ll explore later).

However, this does mean that your profit margins will be narrower unless you’re able to sell your items at a higher price point.

For example, a basic T-shirt from Printful can cost anywhere between $12-$25 before shipping, which might eat into your profits if you’re pricing competitively.

Printify partners with multiple print providers, allowing users to choose from a wider range of price points. This flexibility enables better control over your profit margins.

With the discounts offered through Printify Premium, you can maximize profits even further.

For example, a T-shirt from Printify can cost as low as $8.50 (depending on the provider), giving you more breathing room for profit, even at competitive price points.

Winner: Printify – The ability to choose lower-cost print providers and get discounts through Printify Premium leads to better profit margins.

3. Print Quality

Printful is known for its high-quality printing.

They own and manage their fulfillment centers, ensuring consistency and quality control.

Printful offers direct-to-garment (DTG) printing, embroidery, sublimation, and more.

Many users report that Printful’s print colors are vibrant, the prints last longer, and the overall product quality feels premium.

This makes Printful ideal for high-end merchandise and premium brands that prioritize quality over quantity.

Printify works with third-party print providers, which means that print quality can vary depending on the supplier you choose.

While some providers in Printify’s network offer excellent quality, others might not meet the same standards as Printful.

You must carefully select a provider based on reviews and samples to ensure quality control.

Since Printify doesn’t manage its production process, consistency can sometimes be an issue.

Winner: Printful – Superior print quality and consistency make Printful the preferred option for high-quality products.

4. Branding

Printful excels in branding options. It allows custom branding elements, such as adding your brand’s logo, custom labels, packaging inserts, and more.

These options can elevate your brand and create a more professional unboxing experience.

Printful also offers a white-label service, so your customers will never know a third-party service fulfilled their order.

Printify offers more limited branding options since they rely on third-party printers.

While you can add branded labels or inside tags depending on the supplier, the customization range isn’t as extensive as Printful’s.

Printify’s white-label services are also less robust, and the level of branding customization varies between providers.

Winner: Printful – If branding and customization are important to your business, Printful’s extensive options make it the better choice.

5. Order Fulfillment and Shipping

Printful operates its own fulfillment centers across North America, Europe, and other regions, which generally results in faster and more reliable shipping.

They also offer real-time order tracking, and they notify both you and your customers as soon as an order is fulfilled.

Printful’s shipping rates tend to be higher, though, especially for international orders.

Printify, on the other hand, works with a network of print providers spread out globally.

This means that shipping speeds and costs vary greatly depending on the supplier.

However, having a broader supplier network can sometimes work to your advantage, as it allows you to choose suppliers closer to your customers, potentially reducing shipping costs and times.

While this flexibility can be an advantage, it can also lead to inconsistent fulfillment experiences.

Winner: Tie – Printful offers reliability and consistency, while Printify offers flexibility and potentially cheaper shipping, depending on the provider you choose.

6. Customer Service

Printful has a reputation for solid customer service.

They offer 24/7 live chat support, email, and a robust help center with plenty of resources.

Printful’s dedicated support team is generally known for quick responses and helpful solutions, making it easier to address issues like damaged products, late shipments, or technical concerns.

Printify offers email support and live chat for premium users, while free users are limited to email support.

While Printify’s customer support team is generally responsive, there have been occasional reports of delays in resolving complex issues.

Since Printify relies on third-party suppliers, resolving issues sometimes take longer as they need to communicate with the supplier directly.

Winner: Printful – With 24/7 support and a more streamlined issue resolution process, Printful takes the lead here.

7. Integration With Ecommerce Platforms

Printful integrates seamlessly with a wide range of ecommerce platforms, including Shopify, WooCommerce, Etsy, BigCommerce, and more.

The setup process is generally quick and easy, with well-documented instructions and minimal technical difficulties.

Additionally, Printful has its own mobile app for order management, which can be a plus for busy entrepreneurs on the go.

Printify also integrates with major platforms like Shopify, Etsy, and WooCommerce.

However, Printify supports fewer integrations than Printful.

Both platforms offer automated order fulfillment, but Printful’s integrations tend to be a bit more polished and robust, leading to fewer technical hiccups.

Winner: Printful – With a wider range of integrations and better-polished platform support, Printful slightly edges out Printify.

Final Thoughts: Which is Better, Printful or Printify?

• Choose Printful if you prioritize premium quality, branding options, and customer service. Printful is ideal for businesses focusing on higher-quality products and delivering a professional, branded customer experience. However, keep in mind that Printful’s higher product prices and shipping costs could cut into your profit margins.
• Choose Printify if you’re more focused on maximizing profit margins and offering a wider variety of products. Printify’s flexibility with multiple suppliers allows you to find more affordable options, and its lower-cost premium plan makes it more scalable for businesses processing a high volume of orders. The trade-off, however, is that you might have to deal with some variability in print quality and fulfillment.

Ultimately, both Printful and Printify are powerful platforms that can suit different business needs. The right choice for your business will depend on your priorities: quality and branding vs. affordability and variety.

Considering all the features, Printful is the best option.

FAQ: Printful vs Printify

1. Which platform is more affordable: Printful or Printify?
Printify is generally more affordable, especially with its Premium plan, which offers up to 20% discounts on products.

This can significantly improve your profit margins.

On the other hand, Printful’s products tend to be more expensive, but they justify this with superior print quality and additional features.

2. Does Printful or Printify offer better profit margins?
Printify offers better profit margins due to its lower base product costs and the ability to choose from different suppliers.

With Printify Premium, you can also unlock discounts that further increase profitability.

Printful’s higher prices reduce potential margins unless you’re charging premium prices for your products.

3. Which platform has better print quality: Printful or Printify?
Printful is widely regarded for its superior and consistent print quality.

Since they manage their own fulfillment centers, Printful can maintain strict quality control.

Printify’s print quality varies depending on the third-party suppliers you choose, so it may require testing to find the best providers.

4. Can I customize branding with Printful and Printify?
Printful excels in branding options, allowing you to add custom labels, packaging inserts, and logo placements.

They offer a white-label service that makes it easy to build your brand.

Printify’s branding options are more limited and depend on the specific supplier, meaning there’s less consistency in branding customization.

5. Which platform is faster at fulfilling orders?
Printful manages its own fulfillment centers, leading to more reliable shipping times.

Printify works with a wide network of suppliers, so shipping times and costs vary depending on the supplier’s location.

Printify’s flexibility can sometimes result in faster shipping if you choose a supplier close to your customer, but it may not be as consistent as Printful.

6. What is the customer support like on Printful and Printify?
Printful offers 24/7 live chat support and email support, and it is known for its quick and helpful responses.

Printify offers email support for free users and live chat for Premium users, but resolving issues can sometimes take longer due to third-party supplier involvement.

7. Which platform integrates better with e-commerce platforms?
Both Printful and Printify offer integrations with major ecommerce platforms like Shopify, Etsy, and WooCommerce.

However, Printful offers more polished and seamless integrations with additional platforms like BigCommerce, Wix, and Squarespace, making it slightly better in this category.

8. Can I switch between Printful and Printify?
Yes, you can use both platforms simultaneously or switch between them.

Some sellers use both to maximize their product offerings and compare the quality and pricing of similar items.

It’s important to note that the fulfillment process and shipping times may differ between the two platforms.

9. Which platform is better for scaling a business?
Printify, with its cheaper pricing and premium discounts, is better suited for scaling, especially if your priority is maximizing profit margins.

However, if your business focuses on premium products and strong branding, Printful’s quality and customization options could provide better long-term growth.

10. Do I need a monthly subscription to use Printful or Printify?
Both platforms are free to start, but Printful offers a Pro plan at $49/month with extra tools and design features, while Printify’s Premium plan costs $29/month and offers discounts on products.

You can run your store without paying for a subscription on either platform, but subscribing can enhance your profitability and features.

More on Print on Demand: